ESG in India: A Companies Act Perspective Connecting Law, Governance & Sustainability
ESG in India: A Companies Act Perspective
Connecting Law, Governance & Sustainability
1. Introduction: The Legal Spine of ESG in India 2
ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) 2
2. The Companies Act Hooks for ESG 4
2.1 Section 134 & Rule 8 of Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014 4
● Mandatory Board’s Report Disclosures: 4
2.2 Section 135 & Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, 2014 4
2.3 Governance Framework Supporting “G” 5
3. From Principles to Practice: NGRBC & BRSR 5
3.1 The Nine NGRBC Principles – ESG Mapping 5
3.2 BRSR (Business Responsibility & Sustainability Reporting) 7
3.3 BRSR Section-Wise Coverage 7
4. Regulating ESG Ratings: SEBI’s Framework for ESG Rating Providers (ERPs) 9
4.2. Registration Requirements 10
4.3. Governance & Independence 10
4.4. Methodology & Disclosure Norms 10
4.5. Conflict of Interest Management 11
4.7. Why This Matters for Companies 11
5. Practical Compliance Playbook 11
Annual ESG materiality review: 11
Integrating ESG risks in risk registers: 12
Linking management KPIs to ESG performance: 12
Rule 8 disclosures in Board’s Report: 12
CSR Annual Report & CSR-2 MCA filing: 12
Listed entity BRSR/BRSR Core filing timelines: 12
Build internal data trails: 13
Coordinate with auditors/assurance providers early: 13
Map data owners for E, S, G indicators: 13
SEBI’s easing of BRSR Core value-chain reporting burden: 14
New rules on withdrawal of ESG ratings: 14
CSR amendments in pipeline (if any): 14
Shift towards integrated reporting and cross-referencing with global standards (ISSB, GRI): 14
Example: Tata Steel – Integrating Energy Efficiency with Rule 8 and BRSR Principle 6 14
8. Conclusion & Call to Action 15
Making ESG Reporting Strategic: 16
Upcoming ESG Developments in 2025: 16
Real-World Indian ESG Examples: 16
1. Introduction: The Legal Spine of ESG in India
ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance)
is a framework for evaluating a company’s performance and impact beyond financial metrics:
Environmental (E):
How a company manages its interaction with the natural environment — energy use, emissions, waste management, climate change mitigation, resource efficiency.
Social (S):
How it manages relationships with employees, customers, suppliers, and the community — labour practices, diversity, health & safety, human rights, community development.
Governance (G):
How it is directed and controlled — board structure, transparency, ethics, compliance, shareholder rights, and risk management.
In India, ESG is increasingly law-linked, with disclosure and accountability requirements embedded in the Companies Act, 2013, CSR Rules, MCA guidelines, and SEBI’s sustainability reporting frameworks.
Purpose of this Article:
To identify and map the key ESG-related provisions embedded within the Companies Act, 2013 and its subsequent rules and amendments, and to explain how these statutory requirements connect with and support modern ESG reporting frameworks—including the MCA’s National Guidelines on Responsible Business Conduct (NGRBC) and SEBI’s Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) regime. This mapping will help companies understand how legal compliance forms the backbone of ESG performance in India, ensuring alignment with both regulatory expectations and global sustainability standards.
2. The Companies Act Hooks for ESG
2.1 Section 134 & Rule 8 of Companies (Accounts) Rules, 2014
Mandatory Board’s Report Disclosures:
Conservation of energy
Technology absorption
Foreign exchange earnings/outgo
Link to “E” and “S” in ESG.
Boards can go beyond mere check-the-box compliance by making their ESG disclosures more strategic, transparent, and data-rich, which not only satisfies regulators but also builds trust with investors and stakeholders.
2.2 Section 135 & Companies (CSR Policy) Rules, 2014
CSR applicability thresholds.
2% average net profit obligation.
Amendments in 2021–2022:
Unspent CSR Funds → UCSRA / Schedule VII transfer.
Implementation Routes → Eligible implementing agencies registration.
Impact Assessments → ₹10 cr avg CSR obligation + ₹1 cr project outlay; capped spend.
Under Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 (CSR provisions), penalties for non-compliance—particularly after the 2021 amendments—are monetary and apply to both the company and its officers in default
2.3 Governance Framework Supporting “G”
Section 166 (Duties of Directors).
Sections 177 & 178 (Audit Committee, NRC, vigil mechanism).
Schedule IV (Code for Independent Directors).
How boards can formally integrate ESG into governance charters.
3. From Principles to Practice: NGRBC & BRSR
3.1 The Nine NGRBC Principles – ESG Mapping
3.2 BRSR (Business Responsibility & Sustainability Reporting)
Applicability: top 1,000 listed entities under SEBI LODR Reg 34(2)(f).
3.3 BRSR Section-Wise Coverage
4. Regulating ESG Ratings: SEBI’s Framework for ESG Rating Providers (ERPs)
4.1. Background & Objective
Introduced by SEBI in 2023 through amendments to the SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999, creating a dedicated framework for entities offering ESG ratings in India.
Objective: enhance transparency, credibility, and comparability of ESG ratings used by investors, issuers, and other stakeholders.
4.2. Registration Requirements
Any entity providing ESG ratings in India must register with SEBI as an ERP.
Can operate as a separate legal entity or under an existing SEBI-registered Credit Rating Agency.
Must have minimum net worth requirements (e.g., ₹10 crore for standalone ERPs).
4.3. Governance & Independence
Board-level oversight of ESG rating methodologies and conflict-of-interest management.
Independent directors and separation of rating functions from commercial functions to ensure impartiality.
Mandatory internal controls and periodic audits of processes.
4.4. Methodology & Disclosure Norms
Public disclosure of rating methodology, including:
Weightages for E, S, and G factors.
Data sources (self-disclosures, third-party, public domain).
Treatment of missing or unreliable data.
Annual review and updating of methodologies.
Publication of rating scales and what each rating symbol means.
4.5. Conflict of Interest Management
Prohibition on providing ESG consultancy/advisory services to the same entity being rated.
Cooling-off periods between consultancy and rating assignments.
Disclosure of any potential conflicts in public reports.
4.6. Ongoing Compliance
Submission of periodic returns to SEBI.
Cooperation in inspections and investigations.
Immediate reporting of material breaches or systemic issues in rating practices.
4.7. Why This Matters for Companies
Companies engaging with ERPs will need to share accurate, verifiable ESG data.
Discrepancies between company ESG reports (BRSR) and ERP assessments can impact investor perception and capital access.
Opportunity for proactive companies to engage with ERPs early and ensure alignment of ESG strategy with rating criteria.
5. Practical Compliance Playbook
Boardroom Actions:
Annual ESG materiality review:
Each year, boards should reassess which ESG issues are most relevant to their business and stakeholders, considering regulatory changes, market trends, and emerging risks. This ensures ESG priorities stay current and strategically aligned.
Integrating ESG risks in risk registers:
ESG-related risks—such as climate impact, labour unrest, or governance failures—should be embedded in the company’s main risk register. This integrates ESG into enterprise risk management rather than treating it as a separate silo.
Linking management KPIs to ESG performance:
Key performance indicators for senior management should include measurable ESG targets, such as emissions reduction or diversity goals. This ties leadership incentives directly to sustainable outcomes.
Disclosure Calendar:
Rule 8 disclosures in Board’s Report:
Companies must report on aspects like energy conservation, technology absorption, foreign exchange, and other ESG-related metrics under Rule 8. This ensures transparency and statutory compliance in the annual Board’s Report.
CSR Annual Report & CSR-2 MCA filing:
Companies covered under Section 135 must publish their CSR activities and spend in the Board’s Report and submit the CSR-2 form to the MCA. This documents compliance and provides visibility on social initiatives.
Listed entity BRSR/BRSR Core filing timelines:
Top listed entities are required to submit BRSR or BRSR Core disclosures annually along with their financial statements. BRSR Core requires phased assurance of select KPIs to improve credibility and investor confidence.
Assurance Readiness:
Build internal data trails:
Maintain clear, verifiable records of all ESG-related data, including energy use, emissions, social initiatives, and governance actions. This ensures that reported metrics can be traced and validated during audits.
Coordinate with auditors/assurance providers early:
Engage auditors or third-party assurance providers at the start of the reporting cycle to align on methodology, scope, and data requirements. Early coordination reduces discrepancies and strengthens credibility.
Map data owners for E, S, G indicators:
Assign responsibility for collecting and verifying environmental, social, and governance data to specific individuals or teams. This ensures accountability and timely reporting of accurate ESG metrics.
6. What’s Changing in 2025
SEBI’s easing of BRSR Core value-chain reporting burden:
SEBI has relaxed certain requirements for reporting ESG performance across the supply chain, reducing compliance pressure on listed entities while maintaining disclosure quality.
New rules on withdrawal of ESG ratings:
SEBI now allows ESG rating providers to withdraw ratings under defined conditions, providing clarity and accountability in the ESG ratings ecosystem.
CSR amendments in pipeline (if any):
Upcoming CSR amendments may refine spending rules, reporting formats, or implementation mechanisms, aiming to improve transparency and impact measurement.
Shift towards integrated reporting and cross-referencing with global standards (ISSB, GRI):
Companies are increasingly aligning ESG disclosures with global frameworks like ISSB and GRI, facilitating comparability and supporting international investor expectations.
7. Case Examples
Example: Tata Steel – Integrating Energy Efficiency with Rule 8 and BRSR Principle 6
Context:
Tata Steel, a leading steel manufacturer, aligns its energy efficiency initiatives with both Rule 8 disclosures and BRSR Principle 6, focusing on environmental stewardship.
Implementation:
Rule 8 Disclosures: The company reports on energy conservation measures, technology absorption, and the impact on product cost reduction, as mandated by Rule 8.
BRSR Principle 6: Tata Steel aligns its energy efficiency data with Principle 6 metrics by reporting on specific energy consumption (SEC) and specific water consumption (SWC) figures, as recommended by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE). (cseindia.org)
Outcome:
This dual reporting approach ensures compliance with statutory requirements while enhancing transparency and accountability in environmental performance.
8. Conclusion & Call to Action
ESG in India is already law-backed, not just a voluntary corporate initiative.
Companies that treat ESG as compliance only risk being reactive; those that embed ESG in governance will be future-ready.
Encourage proactive, integrated ESG strategies that speak to regulators, investors, and society.
Summary of the Article
Key ESG-Linked Provisions:
Section 134 & Rule 8: Board’s Report disclosures on energy, technology absorption, foreign exchange, and ESG-related initiatives.
Section 135 & CSR Rules: Mandatory 2% CSR spend, impact assessment, unspent CSR account, and reporting formats.
BRSR/BRSR Core: Top 1000 listed entities must file principle-wise ESG disclosures with phased assurance for KPIs.
Making ESG Reporting Strategic:
Link management KPIs to ESG targets—e.g., emissions reduction or workforce diversity.
Maintain audit-ready data trails for environmental and social metrics.
Engage assurance providers early to align on methodology and data requirements.
Upcoming ESG Developments in 2025:
SEBI easing BRSR Core value-chain reporting requirements to reduce compliance burden.
New rules allowing withdrawal of ESG ratings by rating providers under defined conditions.
Potential CSR amendments to improve transparency and impact measurement.
Increasing adoption of integrated reporting, cross-referencing global standards like ISSB and GRI.
Real-World Indian ESG Examples:
Tata Steel: Integrates energy efficiency data from Rule 8 into BRSR Principle 6 metrics, reporting on specific energy and water consumption. (Tata Steel Sustainability Report)
Infosys: Aligns CSR thematic areas such as education and rural development with NGRBC principles and SDGs, e.g., SDG 1 (No Poverty), SDG 2 (Zero Hunger). (Infosys CSR Report)
Comments
Post a Comment